In light of the recent happening at the Philippine counterpart of the popular, multi-country talent Got Talent franchise, Pilipinas Got Talent, I found myself asking: Were Robin Padilla's action justified? Or were they necessary, at least? And to top it all off, this incident hit very close to home as, I, myself, am an expatriate at a foreign country, the UAE, and have been so for quite a lengthy amount of time. However, until now, I am not capable of holding a conversation in Arabic. Therefore, have I neglected my social responsibility to the language? Or can my situational reasoning make up for its lack thereof? Unfortunately, the video above does not have English subtitles available so for my non-Filipino readers (and for those who didn't even bother to watch the whole thing), here's a quick summary of what happened. Jiwan Kim auditioned as a magician at Pilipinas Got Talent. During the initial interview, we find out that Jiwan has been living as an expat in the Philippines for 10 years; and, he has a Filipina girlfriend. That's all well and good until he asks Judge Robin Padilla to be the participant in his magic trick attempt. At first, Robin refuses for he insists that Jiwan should speak Tagalog as he is, afterall, in Pilipinas Got Talent. Jiwan eventually gets to perform the magic trick, however, with the help of Judge Angel Locsin who translates his words to Tagalog so that he can use them to speak to Robin. After the performance and before the Yes/No voting started, Robin expressed his apologies to how harsh he might've sounded, saying that it was just a disciplining act 'from father to son'. He even goes on to praise Jiwan for being able to perform under pressure. And with that, Jiwan was accepted onto the next round after a Yes from 3 out of 4 judges. And no, that no did not come from Robin, but from Judge Freddie M. Garcia (commonly referred to as simply Judge FMG). As expected, the incident blew up online and many criticised Robin for being "racist and rude". The audition video (posted above) is also now trending on Youtube. WHEW! That was a lot, but here's more. Now that I've introduced to you the situation, I want to dissect the incident further to determine whether the reactions presented in this event are rightfully justified or simply unnecessary. Point #1: Language Being the nerdy kid that I am, you bet that I have a few opinions about how the language used in the exchange affected the whole incident. And no, I'm not talking about the use of Filipino vs. English but rather the use of tone and loaded language, etc. Let's get technical:
point#2: Live humiliation The main reason people had for the online backlash on Judge Robin Padilla was that his 'fatherly scolding' humiliated Jiwan Kim in front of a packed audience, as well as television viewers at home. Personally, I thought it was unnecessary. That's that. I've found a few people online who agree with me on this point and they commented that such a thing could have just been done backstage. Why did it have to be broadcast to everyone? It's not like he committed a crime or any major act of delinquency. In fact, for anyone who's unlike me and reads way too much into someone else's words, he'd have done nothing wrong at all. So, was it necessary for him to be humiliated live? . . . Perhaps, yes. While writing this post, I opened up the topic with a friend of mine, explained to her what had happened, and shared with her these, my opinions on the topic. And, she was actually the one who told me the answer to the question above. She said, "I'm assuming that partially, he (Robin) would make it such a big deal for more publicity, everyone loves a little heat and drama." Ahhh yes, whilst getting triggered over this whole event, I forgot that PGT isn't live and all the auditions that occur aren't shown on TV. Let's say that Judge Robin's reaction had been genuine and not, perhaps, scripted, the production company could have just edited the scene out, in order to avoid more "drama" with more people reacting on the situation. But no, Jiwan's full audition had been shown both on TV and uploaded online on PGT's official YouTube account. In retrospect, are we, the netizens, the ones getting played here? the verdict Judge Robin Padilla's reaction had been justified to an extent but was unnecessary regardless. Check back to Point #1 and that's pretty much my main argument to justify Judge Robin's actions. And just a small point to add, it wouldn't have been extremely difficult for Jiwan to learn a few Tagalog phrases for his audition. His trick was simple enough to be spoken in Tagalog if he tried. Even without Robin's reaction, speaking broken Tagalog could've earned him a few brownie points to impress the judges and the audience even more. However, at the end of the day, if I didn't nit-pick on Jiwan's language, I wouldn't have much to work with as to explaining how and why he had to endure such humiliation. I just think that the 'scolding could've been done differently, nicely. As petty a detail as Jiwan's question, "Robin, can I use you?" that's the only moment that which I thought was a direct cause of Robin's actions. . . . ... but hey, it's just a theory, a tv show theory!... and, cut!...
0 Comments
|
Notes from the author: If you'd like to have a conversation with me about anything I've written in this blog, JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, memes, or anything at all, slide into my DMs at:
The cover artwork featured above is used with special permission from IG: @squackoud
Special hashtags to watch out for:*** the following are specialised blog entries that have no set schedule compared to the usual bi-weekly postings.
#WednesdayWritings - drabbles, poetry, prose, short stories--- creative and expressive writing in no one's style.
#ThrowbackThursday - the cringey, the I-did-that? moments, the tear-inspiring, and the embarrassing moments of the past gone by--- available only here so shhhh...
#FreeThoughtFriday - a collection of 3AM thoughts for your collective amusement and might get you asking wtf?!
to see older posts:To view some of my older posts, there is a "previous" button hiding just below the bottom left corner of the last post of this page.
Categories
All
Archives
October 2022
|